Skip to content
RootMention
Original ResearchWave 1: 41 Verified Shopify Brands (500-Brand Study)Real Data Only, Zero Fabricated ScoresNovember 20, 2026

500 Shopify supplement brands in AI search

Live Wave 1 findings across 41 verified Shopify supplement storefronts (out of 50 audited in the starter cohort toward our 500-brand benchmark), measured across 30 standardized ChatGPT buyer prompts and 30 non-branded Google AI Overview category queries.

01. Executive measurements

Evaluated cohort: 41 brands

Mentioned in ChatGPT
31.7%

13 of 41 brands across 30 prompts

Cited in Google AI Overviews
29.3%

12 of 41 brands across 30 queries

Cited in either AI surface
39.0%

61.0% (25) uncited

Top structural lift
+27.5 pp

COA / Lab Proof

02. Study charts & Datawrapper exports

Every native chart below is generated from the exact same aggregation output as its downloadable Datawrapper CSV. Journalists and analysts can import any CSV straight into Datawrapper with zero reformatting.

Figure 1 · Datawrapper Chart A

AI Search Visibility by Supplement Sub-Category

Share of verified Shopify supplement brands cited in ChatGPT buyer prompts or Google AI Overviews vs. uncited.

Cited in ChatGPT or Google AIOUncited
Select or hover a row to inspect exact counts
Download Datawrapper CSVStacked Bars · chart-a-subcategory-visibility.csv

Figure 2 · Datawrapper Chart B

Citation Rate by Presence of Third-Party Lab & Proof Pages

Observed AI citation rate among stores with verifiable third-party COA / lab evidence pages and key structural traits vs. stores without them.

Third-party COA & lab evidence pages

Dedicated lab testing, Certificate of Analysis (COA), heavy metals, or NSF/USP/Informed-Sport verification pages or linked batch PDFs accessible from the storefront.

Stores WITH this signal57.1% (8/14)
Stores WITHOUT this signal29.6% (8/27)
Observed lift
+27.5 pp
Relative rate
1.93×
Two-proportion z-test
p = 0.087
Structural signalWith signalWithout signalLiftSignificance
Third-party COA & lab evidence pages57.1% (n=14)29.6% (n=27)+27.5 ppp = 0.087
Comparison & "vs" pages37.5% (n=8)39.4% (n=33)-1.9 ppp = 0.921
Clean product copy, Supplement Facts HTML & FAQ schema37.9% (n=29)41.7% (n=12)-3.8 ppp = 0.824
Reddit & independent review corroboration41.7% (n=24)35.3% (n=17)+6.4 ppp = 0.680
AI & search crawler access (OAI-SearchBot & Googlebot)39.0% (n=41)— (n=0)——
Download Datawrapper CSVGrouped Bars or Dot Plot (Range Plot) · chart-b-lab-proof-citation-rate.csv

Figure 3 · Datawrapper Chart C

Top 10 Most-Cited Shopify Supplement Brands Overall

Total distinct AI prompt and Google AI Overview citations across standardized non-branded category queries.

ChatGPT MentionsGoogle AI Overview CitationsClick any brand to inspect evidence
Download Datawrapper CSVStacked Bars (Horizontal) · chart-c-top-10-cited-brands.csv

03. Top 3 structural differences between cited and uncited stores

Rather than inventing opaque readiness scores, each storefront is checked for five observable, binary facts: third-party COA / lab pages, comparison (“vs”) pages, plain-text product/FAQ copy with schema, Reddit & review corroboration, and AI crawler access. The three largest observed citation-rate gaps are surfaced automatically.

Difference 01 · 1.93× rate

Third-party COA & lab evidence pages

Dedicated lab testing, Certificate of Analysis (COA), heavy metals, or NSF/USP/Informed-Sport verification pages or linked batch PDFs accessible from the storefront.

Cited stores
50.0%
Uncited stores
24.0%
Citation lift: +27.5 ppp = 0.087

Difference 02 · 1.18× rate

Reddit & independent review corroboration

Independent buyer discussion threads on Reddit and off-site review profiles that corroborate brand claims outside the merchant's own domain.

Cited stores
62.5%
Uncited stores
56.0%
Citation lift: +6.4 ppp = 0.680

Difference 03 · 0.95× rate

Comparison & "vs" pages

Dedicated product or brand comparison pages (e.g., /compare, /vs, "X vs Y") answering head-to-head buyer questions directly on the domain.

Cited stores
18.8%
Uncited stores
20.0%
Citation lift: -1.9 ppp = 0.921

04. Inspect the brand cohort

Search brands in the current roster (41 loaded), filter by sub-category or COA proof status, and verify individual storefront signals.

Showing 25 of 41 matching brands

Brand & domainSub-categoryChatGPTGoogle AIOCOA / LabCompare / vsFAQ & Schema
Transparent Labstransparentlabs.comProtein Powder75YesYesYes
Momentouslivemomentous.comProtein Powder82YesNoYes
Promix Nutritionpromixnutrition.comProtein Powder10YesNoYes
Truvanitruvani.comProtein Powder10NoNoNo
LMNTdrinklmnt.comElectrolytes & Hydration31YesNoYes
Liquid I.V.liquid-iv.comElectrolytes & Hydration11NoNoYes
Cure Hydrationcurehydration.comElectrolytes & Hydration01YesNoYes
Waterboywaterboy.comElectrolytes & Hydration00NoNoNo
Buoyjustaddbuoy.comElectrolytes & Hydration00NoNoYes
Bloom Nutritionbloomnu.comGreens & Superfoods10NoNoNo
Grünsgruns.coGreens & Superfoods00NoNoYes
IM8im8health.comGreens & Superfoods00YesYesYes
Live it Upletsliveitup.comGreens & Superfoods00NoYesYes
Ghost Lifestyleghostlifestyle.comCreatine & Pre-Workout00NoNoNo
Gorilla Mindgorillamind.comCreatine & Pre-Workout00NoNoYes
Vital Proteinsvitalproteins.comCollagen & Joint Health22NoNoYes
Further Foodfurtherfood.comCollagen & Joint Health00YesNoYes
Dose & Codoseandco.comCollagen & Joint Health00NoNoNo
Sparkle Wellnesslovesparkle.lifeCollagen & Joint Health00NoYesNo
Pendulumpendulumlife.comGut Health & Probiotics00NoNoYes
Just Thrivejustthrivehealth.comGut Health & Probiotics00NoNoYes
Ritualritual.comGut Health & Probiotics33NoNoNo
Armratryarmra.comGut Health & Probiotics00NoNoNo
Beamshopbeam.comSleep & Magnesium00YesNoYes
Moon Juicemoonjuice.comSleep & Magnesium00NoNoYes
Page 1 of 2

05. Standardized prompt bank & methodology

Every sub-category is evaluated against three fixed non-branded ChatGPT buyer prompts and three non-branded Google AI Overview queries—no brand names appear in any query so every brand competes on equal footing.

ChatGPT buyer prompts · Protein Powder

  1. What are the best third-party tested whey or plant protein powders without artificial sweeteners?
  2. Which protein powder brands publish heavy metal lab testing or COAs?
  3. What is the best protein powder for a sensitive stomach that actually dissolves well?

Google AI Overview queries · Protein Powder

  1. best clean protein powder third party tested
  2. protein powder without artificial sweeteners or gums
  3. best protein powder for sensitive stomach

Entity matching & verification

Citations are matched deterministically—never guessed by a secondary LLM. First, any URL cited in an AI answer whose host matches a brand’s verified root domain is recorded as a direct URL citation. Second, brand names and curated aliases are matched on clean word boundaries with explicit exclusion phrases to eliminate false positives on short brand names (for example, distinguishing “Seed” the probiotic brand from “flax seed” or “chia seed”).

Storefront structural traits are verified by live HTTP inspection of each brand’s homepage, /robots.txt, /sitemap.xml, and discovered product, COA/testing, and comparison pages.

Honest limitations

AI answers vary across sessions, models, and dates. Every percentage in this report represents a timestamped snapshot across standardized prompts—not a permanent ranking or a guarantee that adding a COA or comparison page alone causes an AI citation.

Structural comparisons measure correlation across the audited Shopify cohort and report exact sample sizes (n) and two-proportion z-test p-values so readers can judge statistical weight directly.

Get your free audit (results on the next screen)

We check your homepage and up to two key pages and give you up to three priorities. No payment needed.

What the free audit checks
  • Indexing directives
  • Page titles
  • H1 headings
  • Meta descriptions
  • Canonical tags
  • Image alt text
  • Internal links
  • HTTPS
  • Structured data
  • AI crawler access
Get free auditAutomated check of public HTML. No call needed.